Achieving Clear Mixes with Separation: Understanding Frequency Masking

The Key to Clarity in Mixing

One of the biggest challenges in mixing is achieving a clear and balanced sound where every instrument has its own space. That clarity comes down largely to handling frequency masking -- where two instruments occupy the same frequency range, making it difficult to distinguish between them. Imagine trying to see a red dot on a red background—it blends in. The same happens in audio when similar sounds clash.

Black and Red squares with red dot overlay

Understanding Frequency Masking

Frequency masking occurs when two instruments share the same tonal range and are panned to the same part of the stereo field. For example, if both an electric guitar and an accordion are producing similar mid-range frequencies from the right speaker, they can interfere with each other, making it hard to hear either clearly.

A well-balanced mix requires handling this issue effectively. Let's explore some techniques to overcome frequency masking and create a mix where every element is easily heard.

Using EQ to Reduce Frequency Masking

A frequency analyzer helps us visualize how different instruments occupy the audio spectrum. For example, a bass guitar might dominate the 40 Hz - 300 Hz range, while an electric guitar takes over from 300 Hz-400Hz and up. However, too much overlap between them can muddy the mix.

Guitar And Bass Frequency Overlap

Guitar And Bass Frequency Overlap

Guitar With Low-End Rolled Off

Guitar With Low-End Rolled Off

Applying EQ to Create Space

  • Rolling off unnecessary lows: If the guitar has low-end frequencies below 20 Hz, they aren't audible but still take up headroom. Below about 100 Hz (depending on the genre), there's not much useful there. Applying a high-pass filter, or low shelf cut can clean up this range, allowing the bass guitar to come through more clearly.
  • Finding a balance: Cutting too much low-end from the guitar can make it lose warmth. The key is to find a sweet spot where the bass gets clarity without making the guitars sound thin.
  • These principles work for all instruments. Where frequencies overlap between instruments, you can cut the frequencies on one instrument (or boost on the other).
  • You can sometimes boost/cut complimentary areas across two instruments. In other words, cut 1 kHz on the vocal but boost it on the guitar. Boost 2.5 kHz on the vocal and cut it on the guitar.
  • Although we mix with our ears, a frequency analyzer can help visualize how the instruments are distributed across the stereo spectrum.

Panning for Clarity

Another way to prevent frequency masking is by strategically panning instruments. In most rock, country and pop mixes, the kick drum, bass guitar, snare, and lead vocals are panned to the center. Other instruments like guitars, keyboards, and cymbals are often spread across the stereo field.

How Panning Reduces Masking

  • If two similar-sounding instruments are clashing, panning one left and the other right makes them more distinguishable.
  • A lead vocal in the center with guitars panned outward minimizes competition between them. This principle works for all instruments.
  • Mid/Side monitoring can help. Listening to the mid channel (mono signals that are panned up the middle) and the side channel (sounds that are different from left to right) can guide us as to what's conflicting.

Side Chaining for Separation

Side chaining is a technique where one instrument is automatically lowered in volume when another plays. This is especially useful for bass guitar and kick drum, which both occupy the low-end frequencies but need to be heard clearly.

Bass guitar tends to be more constant and kick drum intermittent. So we duck (turn down) the bass when the kick plays.

Example: Side Chaining Bass and Kick Drum With Dynamic EQ

  • A dynamic EQ is set to reduce bass frequencies in the bass guitar when the kick plays, making room for the low-end of the kick drum to cut through.
  • The result is a tighter, more powerful low-end in the kick and a smoother low-end overall.
Sidechaining Using the Tukan Green Dynamic EQ

Sidechaining Low-End In The Bass Guitar Using the Tukan Green Dynamic EQ

Arrangement and Frequency Separation

While mixing techniques can help, arrangement also plays a crucial role in achieving clarity. If two instruments are constantly clashing, consider adjusting the way they are played or layered.

Arranging for Clarity

  • Example: If rhythm guitars and keyboards occupy the same frequency range, consider playing either the guitars or the keyboards an octave higher or changing to a higher voicing.
  • Instead of relying solely on EQ, arrange parts so they naturally complement each other to make mixing easier and the final product more polished.
  • Pan similar sounds away from each other. Plan for that before you record, if possible.

Do You Even Want Clarity In Your Mix?

Clarity isn't always the goal when you're mixing. Sounding like a big mess also conveys emotions. Just remember to follow the guidelines in the article when you want clarity, an throw them out when you don't 🙂

Wrap-up

Achieving a clear, well-separated mix is about more than just turning up volumes. By addressing frequency masking with EQ, panning instruments to different positions, side chaining where necessary, and making thoughtful arrangement choices, you can create mixes where every instrument has its own space.

Happy mixing!

About the author

Keith Livingston

Keith Livingston started recording his own music in the late '70s, on a 4-track. He worked his way into live sound and studio work as an engineer -- mixing in arenas, working on projects in many major studios as a producer/engineer, and working in conjunction with an independent label.

He taught audio engineering at the Art Institute of Seattle, from 1990-1993, and in '96, contributing to authoring several college-level courses there.

He was General Manager of Радио один (Radio 1) in St. Petersburg, Russia.

Now he spends his time recording his own songs wherever he roams, and teaching others to do the same.

You might also like

{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}
>